This one takes the cake, literately.
Today I finally finished the voting cake wall in my market plot. I took the trip back to my home to make sure that no more of my villager have gone missing (taken by aliens I presumed). I determined that no more villagers are missing. Having that chore done I warped back to the market to bask in the glory that is the cake wall.

It is gone! My cake wall is gone! How can my hard won cake wall be gone? Did I loose in the trip to check on my villagers (we know I have lost things before).
When I get back home I see no cake and the entire head collection is missing and these signs on my wall.

Having aligned themselves with the vast creeper plot they the missing villagers even sent me this proof of their dastardly deed.

If you can find the lost cake and guardian head collection and take it from the mutinous villager before they get eaten by zombies (or eat my cake) you may keep anything that they have taken as bounty.

Clues to the location will be listed here and at my shop in game.

1) Bunnies and not the killer kind.
2) Not really underground.
3) There is no cake in Ateph, maybe the next version.
4) Not a cactus in sight.
5) It snows down in Africa, not so much here, a little over there.
6) Hemisphere which contains the Antarctic if Pearl was a sphere.
7) I think that is granite over there.

 

Yes if you find it you take what you want, maybe even claim the area.
There will be clues.

 

The CAKE is a lie!

But the Head collection is real ..

This may be an odd thought, but could the area be in a Desert, or the Ocean? It doesn't appear so to me.
I noticed that there is some snow around ... Hmmm ... Ill keep looking.

 

Congratulations.
I hope you found the chest with the extra goodies those villagers took. Looks like they wanted to make a new settlement.

 

Yay! Congrats Ashash!! Nice job.